We shall now go back to the endings in search of a few more principles, then again to the middle-game, and finally to the openings once more, so that the advance may not only be gradual but homogeneous. In this way the foundation on which we expect to build the structure will be firm and solid.
2.1 Cardinal Principle
In the position shown above, White can draw by playing b4 according to the general rule that governs such cases, i.e. to advance the Pawn that is free from opposition. But suppose that White, either because he does not know this principle or because he does not, in this case, sufficiently appreciate the value of its application;
suppose, we say, that he plays a4. Then Black can win by playing …a5 applying one of the cardinal principles of the high strategy of chess—
A unit that holds two. In this case one Pawn would hold two of the opponent’s Pawns. The student cannot lay too much stress on this principle. It can be applied in many ways, and it constitutes one of the principal weapons in the hands of a master.
Example 22
The example given should be sufficient proof. We give a few moves of the main variation:—
1. a4 a5 2. Kg2 Kf4
Best; see why.
3. b4 axb4
Best
4. a5 b3 5. a6 b2 6. a7 b1Q 7. a8Q Qe4+ 8. Qxe4 Kxe4
This brings the game to a position (shown above as the final position of Example 22) which is won by Black, and which constitutes one of the classical endings of King and Pawns. I shall try to explain the guiding idea of it to those not familiar with it.
2.2 A Classical Ending
Example 23
In this position White’s best line of defence consists in keeping his Pawn where it stands at h2. As soon as the Pawn is advanced it becomes easier for Black to win. On the other hand, Black’s plan to win (supposing that White does not advance his Pawn) may be divided into three parts. The first part will be to get his King to h6 at the same time keeping intact the position of his Pawns. (This is all important, since, in order to win the game, it is essential at the end that Black may be able to advance his rearmost Pawn one or two squares according to the position of the White King.)
9. Kg3 Ke3 10. Kg2
10. Kg4 Kf2 11. h4 g6 will win.
10... Kf4 11. Kf2 Kg5 12. Kg2 Kh4 13. Kg1 Kh3
The first part has been completed. The second part will be short and will consist in advancing the g and h Pawns up the g file.
14. Kh1 h5 15. Kg1 h4
This ends the second part.
The third part will consist in timing the advance of the g Pawn so as to play …g3 when the White King is at h1. It now becomes evident how necessary it is to be able to move the g Pawn either one or two squares according to the position of the White King, as indicated previously.
In this case, as it is White’s move, the Pawn will be advanced two squares since the White King will be in the corner, but if it were now Black’s move the g Pawn should only be advanced one square since the White King is at g1.
16. Kh1 g5 17. Kg1 g4 18. Kh1 g3 19. hxg3
If Kg1 g2.
19... hxg3 20. Kg1 g2 21. Kf2 Kh2
and wins.
It is in this analytical way that the student should try to learn. He will thus train his mind to follow a logical sequence in reasoning out any position. This example is excellent training, since it is easy to divide it into three stages and to explain the main point of each part.
The next subject we shall study is the simple opposition, but before we devote our time to it I wish to call attention to two things.
2.3 Obtaining A Passed Pawn
When three or more Pawns are opposed to each other in some such position as the one in Example 24, there is always a chance for one side or the other of obtaining a passed Pawn.
Example 24
In the following position the way of obtaining a passed Pawn is to advance the centre Pawn.
1. b6 axb6
if …cxb6 a6
2. c6 bxc6 3. a6
and as in this case the White Pawn is nearer to Queen than any of the Black Pawns, White will win. Now if it had been Black’s move Black could play.
1... b6 2. cxb6 cxb6
It would not be advisable to try to obtain a passed Pawn because the White Pawns would be nearer to Queen than the single Black Pawn.
3. axb6 axb6
and the game properly played would be a draw. The student should work this out for himself.
2.4 How To Find Out Which Pawn Will Be First To Queen
When two Pawns are free, or will be free, to advance to Queen, you can find out, by counting, which Pawn will be the first to succeed.
Example 25
In this position whoever moves first wins.
The first thing is to find out, by counting, whether the opposing King can be in time to stop the passed Pawn from Queening. When, as in this case, it cannot be done, the point is to count which Pawn comes in first. In this case the time is the same,
but the Pawn that reaches the eighth square first and becomes a Queen is in a position to capture the adversary’s Queen when he makes one. Thus:
1. a4 h5 2. a5 h4 3. b6 axb6
Now comes a little calculation. White can capture the Pawn, but if so, will not, when Queening, command the square where Black will also Queen their Pawn. Therefore, instead of taking, plays:
4. a6 b5 5. a7 b4 6. a8Q
and wins. The student would do well to acquaint themselves with various simple endings of this sort, so as to acquire the habit of counting, and thus be able to know with ease when one can or cannot get there first. Once again I must call attention to the fact that a book cannot by itself teach how to play. It can only serve as a guide, and the rest must be learned by experience, and if a teacher can be had at the same time, so much the faster will the student be able to learn.
2.5 The Opposition
When Kings have to be moved, and one player can, by force, bring their King into a position similar to the one shown in the following diagram, so that his adversary is forced to move and make way, the player obtaining that advantage is said to have the opposition.
Example 26
Suppose in the above White plays
1. Kd4
Now Black has the option of either opposing the passage of the White King by playing …Kd6 or, if preferred, reply by moving the King thus …Kd6.
Notice that the Kings are directly opposed to each other, and the number of intervening squares between them is odd—one in this case.
The opposition can take the form shown above, which can be called actual or close frontal opposition; or this form:
which can be called actual or close diagonal opposition, or, again, this
form:
which can be called actual or close lateral opposition.
In practice they are all one and the same. The Kings are always on squares of the same colour, there is only one intervening square between the Kings, and the player who has moved last ”has the opposition.”
Now, if the student will take the trouble of moving each King backwards as in a game in the same frontal, diagonal or lateral line respectively shown in the diagrams, we shall have what may be called distant frontal, diagonal and lateral opposition respectively.
The matter of the opposition is highly important, and takes at times somewhat complicated forms, all of which can be solved mathematically; but, for the present, the student should only consider the most simple forms. (An examination of some of the examples of King and Pawns endings already given will show several cases of close opposition.)
In all simple forms of opposition, when the Kings are on the same line and the number of intervening squares between them is even, the player who has the move has the opposition.
Example 27
This position shows to advantage the enormous value of the opposition. The position is very simple. Very little is left on the board, and the position, to a beginner, probably looks absolutely even. It is not the case, however. Whoever has the move wins. Notice that the Kings are directly in front of one another, and that the number of intervening squares is even. Now as to the procedure to win such a position. The proper way to begin is to move straight up. Thus:
1. Ke2 Ke7 2. Ke3 Ke6 3. Ke4 Kf6
Now White can exercise the option of either playing Kd5 and thus passing with his King, or of playing Kf4 and prevent the Black King from passing, thereby keeping the opposition. Mere counting will show that the former course will only lead to a draw, therefore White takes the latter course and plays:
4. Kf4 Kg6
If 4…Ke6 5. Kg5 will win.
5. Ke5 Kg7
Now by counting it will be seen that White wins by capturing Black’s Knight Pawn. The process has been comparatively simple in the variation given above, but Black has other lines of defence more difficult to overcome. Let us begin anew.
1. Ke2 Kd8
Now if 2.Kd3Kd7 or if 2.Ke3Ke7, and Black obtains the opposition in both cases. (When the Kings are directly in front of one another, and the number of intervening squares between the Kings is odd, the player who has moved last has the opposition.)
Now in order to win, the White King must advance. There is only one other square where he can go, Kf3 and that is the right place. Therefore it is seen that in such cases when the opponent makes a so-called waiting move, you must advance, leaving a rank or file free between the Kings. Therefore we have—
2. Kf3 Ke7
Now, it would be bad to advance, because then Black, by bringing up the King in front of your King, would obtain the opposition. It is White’s turn to play a similar move to Black’s first move, viz.:
3. Ke3
Which brings the position back to the first variation shown. The student would do well to familiarise themselves with the handling of the King in all examples of opposition. It often means the winning or losing of a game.
Example 28
The following position is an excellent proof of the value of the opposition as a means of defence.
White is a Pawn behind and apparently lost, yet he can manage to draw as follows:
1. Kh1!
The position of the Pawns does not permit White to draw by means of the actual or close opposition, hence he takes the distant opposition: In effect if 1.Kf1 (actual or close opposition), 1. Kh1! Kd2 2. Kf2 Kf3 and White cannot continue to keep the lateral opposition essential to player safety, because of their own Pawn at f6. On the other hand, after the next move, if
1... Kd2 2. Kh2 Kd3 3. Kh3! Ke2 4. Kg2 Ke3 5. Kg3 Kd4 6. Kg4
Attacking the Pawn and forcing Black to play …Ke3 when it is possible to go back to Kg3 as already shown, and always keep the opposition. Going back to the original position, if
1. Kh1! g4
White does not play fxg4 because …e4 will win, but plays:
2. Kg2 Kd2
if 2…gxf3+ 3. Kxf3 e4 will force a draw
3. fxg4 e4
and mere counting will show that both sides Queen, drawing the game.
If the student will now take the trouble to go back to the examples of King and Pawns which I have given in this book, they will realise that in all of them the matter of the opposition is of paramount importance; as, in fact, it is in nearly all endings of King and Pawns, except in such cases where the Pawn-position in itself ensures the win.
2.6 The Relative Value of Knight and Bishop
Before turning our attention to this matter it is well to state now that two Knights alone cannot mate, but, under certain conditions of course, they can do so if the opponent has one or more Pawns.
Example 29
In this position White cannot win, although the Black King is cornered, but in the following position, in which Black has a Pawn,White wins with or without the move. Thus:
In the position where Black has a Pawn, White wins with or without the move. Thus:
1. Nf3 h4
White cannot take the Pawn because the game will be drawn, as explained before.
2. Ne5 h3 3. Nc6 h2 4. Nb5 h1Q 5. Nc7#
The reason for this peculiarity in chess is evident.
White with the two Knights can only stalemate the King, unless Black has a Pawn which can be moved.
Example 30
Although he is a Bishop and a Pawn ahead the following position cannot be won by White.
It is the greatest weakness of the Bishop, that when the H Pawn Queens on a square of opposite colour and the opposing King is in front of the Pawn, the Bishop is absolutely worthless. All that Black has to do is to keep moving his King close to the corner square.
Example 31
In the above position White with or without the move can win. Take the most difficult variation.
1... Kh2 2. Ng4+ Kh1 3. Kf1 g5 4. Kf2 h2 5. Ne3 g4 6. Nf1 g3+ 7. Nxg3#
Now that we have seen these exceptional cases, we can analyse the different merits and the relative value of the Knight and the Bishop. It is generally thought by amateurs that the Knight is the more valuable piece of the two, the chief reason being that, unlike the Bishop,
the Knight can command both Black and White squares. However, the fact is generally overlooked that the Knight, at any one time, has the choice of one colour only. It takes much longer to bring a Knight from one wing to the other. Also, as shown in the following Example, a Bishop can stalemate a Knight; a compliment which the Knight is unable to return.
Example 32
The weaker the player the more terrible the Knight is to him, but as a player increases in strength the value of the Bishop becomes more evident to him, and of course there is, or should be, a corresponding decrease in his estimation of the value of the Knight as compared to the Bishop.
In this respect, as in many others, the masters of to-day are far ahead of the masters of former generations. While not so long ago some of the very best amongst them, like Pillsbury and Tchigorin, preferred Knights to Bishops, there is hardly a master of to-day who would not completely agree with the statements made above.
Example 33
This is about the only case when the Knight is more valuable than the Bishop.
It is what is called a ”block position,” and all the Pawns are on one side of the board. (If there were Pawns on both sides of the board there would be no advantage in having a Knight.) In such a position Black has excellent chances of winning.
Of course, there is an extra source of weakness for White in having their Pawns on the same colour-squares as his Bishop. This is a mistake often made by players. The proper way, generally, in an ending, is to have your Pawns on squares of opposite colour to that of your own Bishop. When you have your Pawns on squares of the same colour the action of your own Bishop is limited by them, and consequently the value of the Bishop is diminished, since the value of a piece can often be measured by the number of squares it commands. While on this subject, I shall also call attention to the fact that it is generally preferable to keep your Pawns on squares of the same colour as that of the opposing Bishop, particularly if they are passed Pawns supported by the King. The principles might be stated thus:
When the opponent has a Bishop, keep your Pawns on squares of the same colour as your opponent’s Bishop.
Whenever you have a Bishop, whether the opponent has also one or not, keep your Pawns on squares of the opposite colour to that of your own Bishop.
Naturally, these principles have sometimes to be modified to suit the exigencies of the position.
Example 34
In this position the Pawns are on one side of the board, and there is no advantage in having either a Knight or a Bishop. The game should surely end in a draw.
Example 35
Now let us add three Pawns on each side to the above position, so that there are Pawns on both sides of the board.
It is now preferable to have the Bishop, though the position, if properly played out, should end in a draw. The advantage of having the Bishop lies as much in its ability to command, at long range, both sides of the board from a central position as in its ability to move quickly from one side of the board to the other.
Example 36
In this position it is unquestionably an advantage to have the Bishop, because, although each player has the same number of Pawns, they are not balanced on each side of the board. Thus, on the King’s side, White has three to two, while on the Queen’s side it is Black that has three to two. Still, with proper play, the game should end in a draw, though White has somewhat better chances.
Example 37
Here is a position in which to have the Bishop is a decided advantage, since not only are there Pawns on both sides of the board, but there is a passed Pawn (g & h Pawn for White, a & b Pawn for Black). Black should have extreme difficulty in drawing this position, if it can do it at all.1
Example 38
Again Black would have great difficulty in drawing this position.
Note 1. Computer analysis gives a +0.1 advantage to White in this position, the situation does not improve much with it being Black’s turn.
The student should carefully consider these positions. I hope that the many examples will help them to understand, in their true value, the relative merits of the Knight and Bishop. As to the general method of procedure, a teacher, or practical experience, will be best. I might say generally, however, that the proper course in these endings, as in all similar endings, is: Advance of the King to the centre of the board or towards the passed Pawns, or Pawns that are susceptible of being attacked, and rapid advance of the passed Pawn or Pawns as far as is consistent with their safety.
To give a fixed line of play would be folly. Each ending is different, and requires different handling, according to what the adversary proposes to do. Calculation by visualising the future positions is what will count.
2.7 How to Mate with a Knight and a Bishop
Now, before going back again to the middle-game and the openings, let us see how to mate with Knight and Bishop, and, then, how to win with a Queen against a Rook.
With a Knight and a Bishop the mate can only be given in the corners of the same colour as the Bishop.
Example 39
In this example we must mate either at a8 or h8. The ending can be divided into two parts. Part one consists in driving the Black King to the last line. We might begin, as is generally done in all such cases, by advancing the King to the centre of the board:
1. Ke2 Ke7
Black, in order to make it more difficult, goes towards the whitesquared corner:
2. Kd3 Kc6 3. Bf4 Kd5 4. Ne2 Kc5 5. Nc3 Kb4 6. Kd4 Ka5 7. Kc5 Ka6 8. Kc6 Ka7 9. Nd5 Ka8
The first part is now over; the Black King is in the white-squared corner.
The second and last part will consist in driving the Black King now from a8 to a1 or h8 in order to mate him. a1 will be the quickest in this position.
10. Nb6+ Ka7 11. Bc7 Ka6 12. Bb8 Ka5 13. Nd5 Ka4 14. Kc5!
Black tries to make for a8 with his King. White has two ways to prevent that, one by 14. Be5 Kb3 15. Ne3 and the other which I give as the text, and which I consider better for the student to learn, because it is more methodical and more in accord with the spirit of all these endings, by using the King as much as possible.
14... Kb3 15. Nb4 Kc3 16. Bf4 Kb3 17. Be5 Ka4 18. Kc4 Ka5 19. Bc7+ Ka4 20. Nd3 Ka3 21. Bb6 Ka4 22. Nb2+ Ka3 23. Kc3 Ka2 24. Kc2 Ka3 25. Bc5+ Ka2 26. Nd3 Ka1 27. Bb4 Ka2 28. Nc1+ Ka1 29. Bc3#
It will be seen that the ending is rather laborious. There are two outstanding features: the close following by the King, and the controlling of the squares of opposite colour to the Bishop by the combined action of the Knight and King. The student would do well to exercise themselves methodically in this ending, as it gives a very good idea of the actual power of the pieces, and it requires foresight in order to accomplish the mate within the fifty moves which are granted by the rules.
2.8 Queen Against Rook
This is one of the most difficult endings without Pawns. The resources of the defence are many, and when used skilfully only a very good player will prevail within the limit of fifty moves allowed by the rules. (The rule is that at any moment you may demand that your opponent mate you within fifty moves. However, every time a piece is exchanged or a Pawn advanced the counting must begin afresh.)
Example 40
his is one of the standard positions which Black can often bring about. Now, it is White’s move. If it were Black’s move it would be simple, as they would have to move their Rook away from the King (find out why), and then the Rook would be comparatively easy to win.
We deduce from the above that the main object is to force the Black Rook away from the defending King, and that, in order to compel Black to do so, we must bring about the position in the diagram with Black to move. Once we know what is required, the way to proceed becomes easier to find. Thus:
1. Qe5+
Not 1. Qa6 Rc7+ 2. Kb6 Rc3+ 3. Kxc3 Stalemate.(The beginner will invariably fall into this trap.)
1... Ka7 2. Qa1 Kb8 3. Qa5
In a few moves we have accomplished our object. The first part is concluded. Now we come to the second part. The Rook can only go to a White square, otherwise the first check with the Queen will win it. Therefore:
3... Rb3 4. Qe5+ Ka8! 5. Qh8+ Ka7 6. Qg7+ Ka8 7. Qg8+ Rb8 8. Qa2#
(The student should find out by themself how to win when …3...Rb14.Qe5+ Ka7)
Example 41
The procedure here is very similar. The things to bear in mind are that the Rook must be prevented from interposing at b1 because of an immediate mate, and in the same way the King must be prevented from going either to a3 or c1.
Example 42
We shall now examine a more difficult position.
Many players would be deceived by this position. The most likely looking move is not the best. Thus suppose we begin:
1. Qe5+ Kf8 2. Kg6 Rd7
The only defence, but, unfortunately, a very effective one, which makes it very difficult for White, since he cannot play 3.Qe6 because of 3.Qe6Kg7+,4.Kf6Rf7+ draws. Nor can he win quickly by Qc5+ because 3.Qc5+ Ke8 4.Kf6Rd6+ driving back the White King.
Now that we have seen the difficulties of the situation let us go back. The best move is:
1. Qg5+ Kh8
If 1…Kh7 2. Qg6+ Kh8 3. Kh6!
2. Qe5+ Kh7! 3 ZZkg5 Ra7!
If 3…Kg7+ 4. Kf6 leads to a position similar to those in Examples 40 and 41.
4. Qe4+ Kg8 5. Qc4+ Kh7 6. Kf6 Rg7 7. Qh4+ Kg8 8. Qh5
and we have the position of Example 40 with Black to move. Let us go back again
1. Qg5+ Kg8 2. Qd8+ Kg7 3. Kg5 Rf3
The best place for the Rook away from the King 3…Kh7 4. Qd4 Rg7+ 5. Kf6 would lead to positions similar to those already seen.
4. Qd4+ Kf8 5. Kg6
5. Qd6+ Kg7 6. Qe5+ Kf8 7. Kg6 would also win the Rook. The next move, however, is given to show the finesse of such endings. White now threatens mate at d8.
5... Rg3+ 6. Kf6 Rf3+ 7. Ke6 Rh3
White threatened mate at h8.
8. Qf4+
and the rook is lost. Note, in these examples, that the checks at long range along the diagonals have often been the key to all the winning manoeuvres. Also that the Queen and King are often kept on different lines. The student should carefully go over these positions and consider all the possibilities not given in the text.
The student should once more go through everything already written before proceeding further with the book.