We must now revert once more to the endings. Their importance will have become evident to the student who has taken the trouble to study my game with Janowski (Example 53). After an uneventful opening a Ruy Lopez in one of its normal variations, my opponent suddenly made things interesting by offering the exchange; an offer which, of course, I accepted. Then followed a very hard, arduous struggle, in which I had to defend myself against a very dangerous attack made possible by the excellent manœuvring of my adversary. Finally, there came the time when I could give back the material and change off most of the pieces, and come to an ending in which I clearly had the advantage. But yet the ending itself was not as simple as it at first appeared, and finally perhaps through one weak move on my part it became a very difficult matter to find a win. Had I been a weak end-game player the game would probably have ended in a draw, and all my previous efforts would have been in vain. Unfortunately, that is very often the case among the large majority of players; they are weak in the endings; a failing from which masters of the first rank are at times not free. Incidentally, I might call attention to the fact that all the world’s champions of the last sixty years have been exceedingly strong in the endings: Morphy, Steinitz, and Dr. Lasker had no superiors in this department of the game while they held their titles.
5.1 The Sudden Attack from a Different Side
I have previously stated, when speaking about general theory, that at times the way to win consists in attacking first on one side, then, granted greater mobility of the pieces, to transfer the attack quickly from one side to the other, breaking through before your opponent has been able to bring up sufficient forces to withstand the attack. This principle of the middle-game can sometimes be applied in the endings in somewhat similar manner.
Example 56
In the above position I, with the Black pieces, played:
1... Re4+ 2. Re2 Ra4 3. Ra2 h5
The idea, as will be seen very soon, is to play …h6 in order to fix White’s King’s side Pawns with a view to the future. It is evident to Black that White wants to bring his King to Kd3 to support his two weak isolated Pawns, and thus to free his Rooks. Black, therefore, makes a plan to shift the attack to the King’s side at the proper time, in order to obtain some advantage from the greater mobility of his Rooks.
4. Rd1 Rda5
In order to force the Rook to Rook’s square, keeping both Rooks tied up.
5. Rda1 h4 6. Kd2 Kg7 7. Kc2 Rg5
Black begins to transfer his attack to the King’s side.
8. Rg1
A serious mistake, which loses quickly. White should have played 8. Kb3 Raa5 9. g3 and Black would have obtained an opening at g6 for his King, which in the end might give him the victory.
8... Rf4
Now the King cannot go to b3 because of …Rb5+.
9. Kd3 Rf3+ 10. Ke2
If 10. gxf3 Rxg1 followed by …Rh1 winning, and Black won after a few moves.
Example 57
Another good example, in which is shown the advantage of the greater mobility of the pieces in an ending, is the following from a game Capablanca- Kupchick played at the Havana Masters Tournament, 1913. The full score and notes of the game can be found in the book of the tournament.
White’s only advantage in the above position is that they possesses the open file and has the move, which will secure them the initiative. There is also the slight advantage of having Pawns on the Queen’s side united, while Black has an isolated a Pawn. The proper course,
as in the previous ending, is to bring the Rooks forward, so that at least one of them may be able to shift from one side of the board to the other, and thus keep Black’s Rooks from moving freely.
What this means in general theory has been stated already; it really means: keep harassing the enemy; force them to use his big pieces to defend Pawns. If he has a weak point, try to make it weaker, or create another weakness somewhere else and his position will collapse sooner or later. If he has a weakness, and he can get rid of it, make sure that you create another weakness somewhere else.
From the position in question the game continued thus:
1. Re4 Rfe8
with the object of repeating White’s manœuvre, and also not to allow White the control of the open file.
2. Rae1 Re6 3. R1e3 Rce8 4. Kf1 Kf8
Black wants to bring his King to the centre of the board in order to be nearer to whatever point White decides to attack. The move is justified at least on the general rule that in such endings the King should be in the middle of the board. He does nothing after all but follow White’s footsteps. Besides, it is hard to point out anything better. If 4…d5 5. Rg4+ Kf8 Black will eventually follow up with …Ke7 this would leave Black in a very disagreeable position. If 4…f5 5. Rd4! Rxe3? 6. fxe3 Rxe3 7. Kf2 Re7 8. Rh4 winning the Pawn on h7 which would practically leave White with a passed Pawn ahead on the Queen’s side, as the three Pawns of Black on the King’s side would be held by the two of White.
5. Kf2 Ke7 6. Ra4 Ra8
The student should note that through the same manœuvre Black is forced into a position similar to the one shown in the previous ending.
7. Ra5!
This move has a manifold object. It practically fixes all of Black’s Pawns except the d Pawn, which is the only one that can advance two squares. It specially prevents the advance of Black’s f Pawns, and at the same time threatens the advance of White’s f Pawns to f4 and f5. By this threat it practically forces Black to play …d4 which is all White desires, for reasons that will soon become evident.
7... d5 8. c4! Kd6
Evidently forced, as the only other move to save a Pawn would have been …dxc4 which would have left all Black’s Pawns isolated and weak. If 8…d4 9. Re4 Kd6 10. b4! Re5 11. Ra6 and Black’s game is hopeless.
9. c5+ Kd7 10. d4 f5
Apparently very strong, since it forces the exchange of Rooks because of the threat Ra6 but in reality it leads to nothing. The best chance was to play …Rae8.
11. Rxe6 fxe6 12. f4
Up to now White had played with finesse, but this last move is weak. Ra6 was the proper way to continue, so as to force Black to give up his a or c Pawn.
12... Kc8 13. Kd2
Again a bad move. The proper continuation, 13. Ra3 Rb8 14. b3 Kb7 15. b4 Ka8 16. Rb3 with excellent winning chances; in fact, I believe, a won game.
13... Kb7
Black misses the only chance. …Rb8 would have drawn.
14. Ra3 Rg8 15. Rh3 Rg7 16. Ke2 Ka6
17. Rh6 Re7 18. Kd3 Kb7
Black goes back with the King to support the e Pawn, and thus be able to utilise the Rook. It is, however, useless, and only White’s weak play later on gives Black further chances of a draw.
19. a4 Kc8 20. Rh5
To prevent the Black Rook from controlling the open file.
20... Kd7 21. Rg5 Rf7 22. Kc3 Kc8
Black must keep the King on that side because White threatens to march with the King to a6 via b4.
23. Kb4 Rf6 24. Ka5 Kb7 25. h4 a6 26. h5 Rh6
Black can do nothing but wait for White. The next move stops White from moving the Rook, but only for one move.
27. b4 Rf6
The only other move was …Ka7 when White could play Rg7 or even b5.
28. b5
A weak move, which gives Black a fighting chance. In this ending, as is often the case with most players, White plays the best moves whenever the situation is difficult and requires careful handling,
but once his position seems to be overwhelming he relaxes his efforts and the result is nothing to be proud of. The right move was 28 Rg7.
28... axb5 29. axb5 Rf8! 30. Rg7 Ra8+ 31. Kb4 cxb5 32. Kxb5 Ra2 33. c6+ Kb8 34. Rxh7 Rb2+ 35. Ka5 Ra2+ 36. Kb4 Rxf2
Black misses the last chance: …Rb7+ forcing the King to c3 in order to avoid the perpetual, would probably draw. The reader must bear in mind that my opponent was then a very young and inexperienced player, and consequently deserves a great deal of credit for the fight he put up.
37. Re7 Rxf4
…Rb2+ followed by …Rg7 offered better chances.
38. h6! Rxd4+ 39. Kb5 Rd1 40. h7 Rb1+ 41. Kc5 Rc1+ 42. Kd4 Rd1+ 43. Ke5 Re1+ 44. Kf6 Rh1 45. Re8+ Ka7 46. h8Q Rxh8 47. Rxh8 Kb6 48. Kxe6 Kxc6 49. Kxf2 Kc5 50. Ke5
Resigns. This ending shows how easy it is to make weak moves, and how often, even in master-play, mistakes are made and opportunities are lost. It shows that, so long as there is no great advantage of material, even with a good position, a player, no matter how strong, cannot afford to relax his attention even for one move.
5.2 The Danger of as Safe Position
Example 58
A good proof of the previous statement is shown in the following ending between Marshall and Kupchick in one of their two games in the same Tournament (Havana, 1913).
It is evident that Marshall (White) is under great difficulties in the above position. Not only is he bound to lose a Pawn, but his position is rather poor. The best he could hope for was a draw unless something altogether unexpected happened, as it did. No reason can be given for Black’s loss of the game except that he felt so certain of having the best of it with a Pawn more and what he considered a safe position, that he became exceedingly careless and did not consider the danger that actually existed. Let us see how it happened.
26. g4 Rxa2
The mistakes begin. This is the first. Black sees that he can take a Pawn without any danger, and does not stop to think whether there is anything better. …Rf2+ was the right move. If then Kg3 Rxa2. If instead White played Ke4 Re5+ then followed by …Rxa2.
27. Rd1 Ra4+
Mistake number two, and this time such a serious one as to almost lose the game. The proper move was to play …f5 in order to break up White’s Pawns and at the same time make room for the Black King, which is actually in danger, as will soon be seen.
28. Rd4 Raa5
Mistake number three and this time fatal. His best move was …Rga5. After the next move there is no defence. Black’s game is lost. This shows that even an apparently simple ending has to be played with care. From a practically won position Black finds himself with a lost game, and it has only taken three moves.
29. Rdd8 Rg7
If 29…f5 30. Rh8+ Kg6 31. Rcg8+ Kf6 32. Rxh6+ Rg6 33. g5+ Ke7 34. Rhxg6 fxg6 35. Rg7+ Ke8 36. Rxg6 and wins easily.
30. h4 h5 31. Rh8+
Resigns. The reason is evident. If …Kg6 32.gxh5+ Rxh5 33.Rxh5Kxh5,34.Rh8+ Kg6 35.h5#
5.3 Endings With One Rook and Pawns
The reader has probably realised by this time that endings of two Rooks and Pawns are very difficult, and that the same holds true for endings of one Rook and Pawns. Endings of two Rooks and Pawns are not very common in actual play; but endings of one Rook and Pawns are about the most common sort of endings arising on the chess board. Yet though they do occur so often, few have mastered them thoroughly. They are often of a very difficult nature, and sometimes while apparently very simple they are in reality extremely intricate. Here is an example from a game between Marshall and Rosenthal in the Manhattan Chess Club Championship Tournament of 1909-1910.
In this position Marshall had a simple win by Rc7+ but played f6 and thereby gave Black a chance to draw. Luckily for him Black did not see the drawing move, played poorly, and lost. Had Black been up to the situation he would have drawn by playing …Rd6.
1. f6 Rd6!
Now White has two continuations either (a) f7 or (b) Rc7+. We have therefore;
(a)
2. f7 Rd8! 3. Rh5+ Kc4
and White will finally have to sacrifice the Rook for Black’s Pawn. Or - (b)
2. Rc7+ Kd4! 3. f7 Rg6+
a very important move, as against …Rf6 Re7 wins.
4. Kf1 Rf6 5. Rb7 Kb6
and White will finally have to sacrifice the Rook for the Pawn, or draw by perpetual check.
If there were nothing more in the ending it would not be of any great value, but there are other very interesting features. Now suppose that after 1.f6Rd6,2.f7 Black did not realise that …Rd8 was the only move to draw. We would then have the following position:
Now there would be two other moves to try: either (a) …Rg6+ or (b) …Rf6. Let us examine them. (a)
2... Rg6+ 3. Kf3 Rf6+ 4. Ke3 Re6+
if 4…b3 5. Rh5 wins, because if the King goes back, then Rh4+ followed by Rf4 wins.
5. Kd3 Rf6
If 5…Rd6 6. Ke4 wins.
6. Rh5+ Kb6 7. Rh6
(b)
2... Rf6 3. Rg7! Kc4
If 3…b3 4. Rg3 and White will either capture the Pawn or go to f3 and come out with a winning ending.
4. h4 b3 5. Rg4+ Kc3 6. Rg3+
and White will either capture the Pawn or play R - K B 3, according to the circumstances, and come out with a winning ending.
Now, going back to the position first shown in this chapter, suppose that after 1.f6Rd6!,2.Rc7+ Black did not realise that …Kd4 was the only move to draw, and consequently played …Kc6 instead, we would then have the following position:
Now the best coninuation would be:
3. f7 Rg6+ 4. Kf1 Rf6 5. Re7! Kc5
White threatened to check with the rook at e6.
6. Ke2 b3
Best. If 6…Kc4 both h4 and Ke3 will win; the last-named move particularly would win with ease.
7. Re3 b2 8. Rb3 Rxf7 9. Rxb2 Rh7 10. Rd2 Rxh2 11. Ke3
This position we have arrived at is won by White, because there are two files between the opposing King and the Pawn from which the King is cut off by the Rook, and besides, the Pawn can advance to the fourth rank before the opponent’s Rook can begin to check on the file.
This last condition is very important, because if, instead of the position on the diagram, the Black Rook were at …Rh8 and Black had the move, he could draw by preventing the advance of the Pawn, either through constant checks or by playing …Rf8 at the proper time.
Now that we have explained the reasons why this position is won, we leave it to the student to work out the correct solution.
The fact that out of one apparently simple ending we have been able to work out several most unusual and difficult endings should be sufficient to impress upon the student’s mind the necessity of becoming well acquainted with all kinds of endings, and especially with endings of Rook and Pawns.
5.4 A Difficult Ending: Two Rooks and Pawns
Following our idea that the best way to learn endings as well as openings is to study the games of the masters, we give two more endings of two Rooks and Pawns. These endings, as already stated, are not very common, and the author is fortunate in having himself played more of these endings than is generally the case. By carefully comparing and studying the endings already given (Examples 56 and 57) with the following, the student no doubt can obtain an idea of the proper method to be followed in such cases. The way of procedure is somewhat similar in all of them.
Example 60
From a game, Capablanca - Kreymborg, in the New York State Championship Tournament of 1910. It is Black’s move, and no doubt thinking that drawing such a position (that was all Black played for) would be easy, he contented himself with a waiting policy. Such conduct must always be criticised.
It often leads to disaster. The best way to defend such positions is to assume the initiative and keep the opponent on the defensive.
21... Rae8
The first move is already wrong. There is nothing to gain by this move. Black should play …a5 to be followed by …a6 unless White plays b3. That would fix the Queen’s side. After that he could decide what demonstration he could make with his Rooks to keep the opponent’s Rooks at bay.
22. Rd4
his move not only prevents …f4 which Black intended, but threatens …b3 followed, after …cxb3+ by the attack with one or both Rooks against Black’s a Pawn.
22... Rf6
probably with the idea of a demonstration on the King’s side by …Rg6 and …Rg2.
23. b3 cxb3+ 24. axb3 Kf7 25. Kd3
Ra1 should have been played now, in order to force Black to defend with …Re7. White, however, does not want to disclose his plan at once, and thus awaken Black to the danger of his position, hence this move, which seems to aim at the disruption of Black’s Queen’s side Pawns.
25... Re7 26. Ra1 Ke6
This is a mistake. Black is unaware of the danger of his position. He should have played …g5 threatening …Rh6 and, by making this demonstration against White’s h Pawn, stop the attack against his Queen’s side Pawns, which will now develop.
27. Ra6 Rc7
He could not play …Kd6 because c4 would win at least a Pawn. This in itself condemns his last move …Ke6 which has done nothing but make his situation practically hopeless.
28. Rda4 g5
Now forced, but it is a little too late. He could not play …R6f7 because f4 would have left his game completely paralysed. Black now finally awakens to the danger, and tries to save the day by the counter-demonstration on the King’s side, which he should have started before. Of course, White cannot play Rxa7 because of …Rxa7 followed by …Rh6 recovering the Pawn with advantage.
29. h4! g4
Black is now in a very disagreeable position. If he played 29…gxh4 30. Rxh4 would leave him in a very awkward situation, as he could not go back with the King, nor could he do much with either Rook. He practically would have to play …h6 when White would answer 31.b4 threatening to win a Pawn by b5 or, if that were not enough, he might play Kd4 to be followed finally by the entry of the King at c5 or e5.
30. Ke2
30... gxf3+
Again he cannot play …h5 because f4 would leave him paralysed. The advance of his h Pawn would make White’s h Pawn safe, and consequently his f6 Rook would have to retire to f2 to defend the a Pawn.
That would make it impossible for his King to go to d2 because of the a Pawn, nor could he advance a single one of his Pawns. On the other hand, White would play b4 threatening to win a Pawn by b5 or he might first play Kd4 and then at the proper time b5 if there was nothing better. Black meanwhile could really do nothing but mark time with one of his Rooks. Compare this bottling-up system with the ending in Example 57, and it will be seen that it is very similar.
31. Kxf3 Rff7 32. Ke2
Probably wrong. b4 at once was the right move.1 The next move gives Black good chances of drawing.
32... Kd6 33. b4 Rb7
This could never have happened had White played 12.b4 as he could have followed it up by b5 after Black’s …Kd6.
34. h5
Not good. f4 offered the best chances of winning by force. If then 34. f4 Rg7 35. h5 Rg2+ 36. Kd3 Rh2 37. Rxa7 Rxa7 38. Rxa7 Rxh5 39. Ra6 with winning chances.
Note 1. Computer analysis disagrees with this assement and suggests Kf4 is the best move.
34... h6
Black misses his last chance. 34…f4 35. exf4 Rbe7+! 36. Kf1 Rxf4 37. Rxa7 Re3!
35. f4 Rg7 36. Kd3 Rge7 37. Ra1 Rg7 38. Kd4 Rg2 39. R6a2 Rbg7
…R2g2 would have offered greater resistance, but the position is lost in any case. (I leave the student to work this out.)
40. Kd3! Rxa2 41. Rxa2 Re7
Nothing would avail. If 41…Rg1 42. Ra6 Rd1+ 43. Kc2 Rh1 44. b5 Rxh5 45. Rxc6+ Kd7 46. Ra6 and White will win easily.
42. Rg2 Re6 43. Rg7 Re7 44. Rg8 c5
Black is desperate. He sees he can no longer defend his Pawns.
45. Rg6+ Re6 46. bxc5+ Kd7 47. Rg7+ Kc6 48. Rxa7 Kxc5 49. Rf7
Resigns
Example 61
Black’s game has the disadvantage of his double c Pawns, which, to make matters worse, he cannot advance, because as soon as Black plays …b6 White replies b4. It is on this fact that White builds his plans. He will stop Black’s Queen’s side Pawns from advancing, and will then bring his own King to e3.
Then in due time he will play d4 and finally e5 or g5 thus forcing an exchange of Pawns and obtaining in that way a clear passed Pawn on the King’s file. It will be seen that this plan was carried out during the course of the game, and that White obtained his winning advantage in that way. The play was based throughout on the chance of obtaining a passed Pawn on the King’s file, with which White expected to win.
27. g4
already preparing to play g5 when the time comes.
27... b6
Black wants to play …c5 but White, of course, prevents it.
28. b4! Kb7
This King should come to the King’s side, where the danger lurks.
29. Kf2 b5
With the object of playing …Kb6 and …a5 followed by bxa2 or …axb4 and thus have an open file for his Rook and be able to make a counterdemonstration on the Queen’s side in order to stop White’s advance on the right. White, however, also prevents this.
30. a4! Rd4
Of course if axb5 Black will have all his Pawns on the Queen’s side disrupted and isolated, and White can easily regain the lost Pawn by playing either Rook on the a file.
31. Rb1 Re5
He still wants to play …c5 but as it is easy to foresee that White will again prevent it, the next move is really a serious loss of time. Black should bring his King over to the other side immediately.
32. Ke3 Rd7 33. a5
The first part of White’s strategic plan is now accomplished. Black’s Pawns on the Queen’s side are fixed for all practical purposes.
33... Re6
If 33…Rxf5 34. gxf5 would have given White a very powerful centre. Yet it might have been the best chance for Black.
34. Rbf1 Rde7 35. g5 fxg5 36. Rxg5
The second part of White’s strategical plan is now accomplished. It remains to find out if the advantage obtained is sufficient to win. White not only has a passed Pawn, but his King is in a commanding position in the centre of the board ready to support the advance of White’s Pawns, or, if necessary, to go to c5
or to move to the right wing in case of danger. Besides, White holds the open file with one of his Rooks. Altogether White’s position is superior and his chances of winning are excellent.
36... Rh6 37. Rg3 Rhe6
to prevent d4. Also Black fears to keep his Rook in front of his two King’s side Pawns which he may want to utilise later.
38. h4 g6 39. Rg5 h6
White threatens h5 which would finally force Black to take, and then White would double his Rooks against the isolated Pawn and win it, or tie up Black’s Rooks completely. The next move, however, only helps White; therefore Black had nothing better than to hold tight and wait. …Re5 would not help much, as White would simply answer 39…Re5 40. Rf8 Re8 41. Rxe5 and whichever Rook Black took, White would have an easy game. (The student should carefully study these variations.)
40. Rg4 Rg7 41. d4 Kb8 42. Rf8+ Kb7
Kd2 would not help much, but since he made the previous move he should now be consistent and play it.
43. e5 g5 44. Ke4 Ree7 45. hxg5 hxg5 46. Rf5 Kc8 47. Rgxg5 Rh7 48. Rh5 Kd7 49. Rxh7 Rxh7 50. Rf8 Rh4+ 51. Kd3 Rh3+ 52. Kd2 c5 53. bxc5 Ra3 54. d5
Resigns. The winning tactics in all these endings have merely consisted in keeping the opponent’s Rooks tied to the defence of one or more Pawns, leaving my own Rooks free for action. This is a general principle which can be equally applied to any part of the game. It means in general terms—
Keep freedom of manœuvre while hampering your opponent. There is one more thing of great importance, and that is that the winning side has always had a general strategical plan capable of being carried out with the means at his disposal, while often the losing side had no plan at all, but simply moved according to the needs of the moment.
5.5 Rook, Bishop and Pawns v. Rook, Knight and Pawns
We shall now examine an ending of Rook, Bishop and Pawns against Rook, Knight and Pawns, where it will be seen that the Rook at times is used in the same way as in the endings already given.
Example 62
From the first game of the Lasker-Marshall Championship Match in 1907.
In this position it is Black’s move. To a beginner the position may look like a draw, but the advanced player will realise immediately that there are great possibilities for Black to win, not only because he has the initiative, but because of White’s undeveloped Queen’s side and the fact that a
Bishop in such a position is better than a Knight. It will take some time for White to bring his Rook and Knight into the fray, and Black can utilise it to obtain an advantage. There are two courses open to him. The most evident, and the one that most players would take, is to advance the Pawn to …c5 and …c6 immediately in conjunction with the Bishop check at a6 and any other move that might be necessary with the Black Rook. The other, and more subtle, course was taken by Black. It consists in utilising his Rook in the same way as shown in the previous endings, forcing White to defend something all the time, restricting the action of White’s Knight and White’s Rook, while at the same time keeping freedom of action for his own Rook and Bishop.
19... Rb8
This forces B3, which blocks that square for the White Knight.
20. b3 Rb5
bringing the Rook to attack the King’s side Pawns so as to force the King to that side to defend them, and thus indirectly making more secure the position of Black’s Queen’s side Pawns.
21. c4 Rh5 22. Kg1 c5
Note that the White Knight’s sphere of action is very limited, and that after Nd2 White’s own Pawns are in his way.
23. Nd2 Kf7 24. Rf1+
This check accomplishes nothing. It merely drives Black’s King where it wants to go. Consequently it is a very bad move. a32 at once was the best move.
24... Ke7 25. a3 Rh6
Getting ready to shift the attack to the Queen’s side, where he has the advantage in material and position.
26. h4 Ra6
Notice how similar are the manœuvres with this Rook to those seen in the previous endings.
27. Ra1 Bg4
Paralysing the action of the Knight and fixing the whole King’s side.
28. Kf2 Ke6
White cannot answer Nf3 because …Bxf3 followed by …Ke5 will win a Pawn, on account of the check at …Rf6+ which cannot be stopped.
29. a4 Ke5 30. Kg2 Rf6 31. Re1 d3 32. Rf1 Kd4
Now the King attacks White’s Pawns and all will soon be over.
33. Rxf6 gxf6 34. Kf2 c6
Merely to exhaust White’s move, which will finally force him to move either the King or the Knight.
Note 2. Computer analysis suggests Nf3 was the best move.
35. a5 a6 36. Nb1 Kxe4 37. Ke1 Be2 38. Nd2+ Ke3 39. Nb1 f5 40. Nd2 h5 41. Nb1 Kf3 42. Nc3 Kxg3 43. Na4 f4 44. Nxc5 f3 45. Ne4+ Kf4
The quickest way to win. White should resign.
46. Nd6 c5 47. b4 cxb4 48. c5 b3 49. Nc4 Kg3 50. Ne3 b2
Resigns. A very good example on Black’s part of how to conduct such an ending.