6.1 Some Salient Points About Pawns
Before going back to the discussion of openings and middle-game positions, it might be well to bear in mind a few facts concerning Pawn positions which will no doubt help to understand certain moves, and sometimes even the object of certain variations in the openings, and of some manœuvres in the middle-games.
In the position of the diagram we have an exceedingly bad Pawn formation on Black’s side. Black’s c Pawn is altogether backward, and White could by means of the open file concentrate their forces against that weak point.
There is also the square at White’s c5 which is controlled by White, and from where a White piece once established could not be dislodged. In order to get rid of it, Black would have to exchange it, which is not always an easy matter, and often when possible not at all convenient. The same holds true with regard to Black’s e, f and g Pawns, which create what is called a ”hole” at f6. Such Pawn formations invariably lead to disaster, and consequently must be avoided.
Example 64
In this position we might say that the White centre Pawns have the attacking position, while the Black centre Pawns have the defensive position.
Such a formation of Pawn occurs in the French Defence. In such positions White most often attempts, by means of f4 and wmovef5, to obtain a crushing attack against Black’s King, which is generally Castled on the King’s side. To prevent that, and also to assume the initiative or obtain material advantage, Black makes a counter-demonstration by …c5 followed by dxc5 (when White defends the Pawn by c3), and the concentrating of Black’s pieces against the White Pawn at d4. This in substance might be said to be a determined attack against White’s centre in order to paralyse the direct attack of White against Black’s King. It must be remembered that at the beginning of the book it was stated that control of the centre was an essential condition to a successful attack against the King.
In an abstract way we may say that two or more Pawns are strongest when they are in the same rank next to one another. Thus the centre Pawns are strongest in themselves, so to speak, when placed at e4 and d4 respectively, hence the question of advancing either the one or the other to the fifth rank is one that must be most carefully considered. The advance of either Pawn often determines the course the game will follow.
Another thing to be considered is the matter of one or more passed Pawns when they are isolated either singly or in pairs. We might say that a passed Pawn is either very weak or very strong, and that its weakness or strength, whichever happens to be in the case to be considered, increases as it advances, and is at the same time in direct relation to the number of pieces on the board. In this last respect it might be generally said that a passed Pawn increases in strength as the number of pieces on the board diminishes.
Having all this clear in mind we will now revert to the openings and middle-game. We will analyse games carefully from beginning to end according to general principles. I shall, whenever possible, use my own games, not because they will better illustrate the point, but because, knowing them thoroughly, I shall be able to explain them more authoritatively than the games of others.
6.2 Some Possible Developments from a Ruy Lopez
That some of the variations in the openings and the manœuvres in the middle-game are often based on some of the elementary principles just expounded can be easily seen in the following case:
Example 65
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3. Bb5 a6 4. Ba4 Nf6 5. O-O Nxe4 6. d4 b5 7. Bb3 d5 8. dxe5 Be6 9. c3 Be7 10. Re1 O-O 11. Nbd2 Nc5 12. Bc2 Bg4 13. Nb3 Ne6
So far a very well-known variation of the Ruy Lopez. In fact, they are the moves of the Janowski-Lasker game in Paris, 1912.
14. Qd3 g6
Let us suppose the game went on, and that in some way White, by playing one of the Knights to d4 at the proper time, forced the exchange of both Knights, and then afterwards both the Bishops were exchanged, and we arrived at some such position as shown in the following diagram.
(I obtained such a position in a very similar way once at Lodz in Poland. I was playing the White pieces against a consulting team headed by Salwe.)
Now we would have here the case of the backward c Pawn for Black, which will in no way be able to advance to d5. Such a position may be said to be theoretically lost, and in practice a first-class master will invariably win it from Black. (If I may be excused the reference, I will say that I won the game above referred to.)
After a few moves the position may be easily thus:
The Black pieces can be said to be fixed. If White plays Qc3 Black must answer …Qd7 otherwise they will lose a Pawn, and if White returns with the Queen to a3 Black will have again to return to b7 with the Queen or lose a Pawn.
Thus Black can only move according to White’s lead, and under such conditions White can easily advance with the Pawns to f4 and g4 until Black will be forced to stop f5 by playing …f5 and we might finally have some such position as this:
In this situation the game might go on as follows:
1. gxf5 gxf5
White threatened to win a Pawn by Qxa6 and Black could not play …Rf8 because Rxc6 would also win a Pawn at least.
2. Qf3 Qd7 3. R5c2 Rg6 4. Rg2 Kh8 5. Rcg1 Rcg8 6. Qh5 Rxg2 7. Rxg2 Rxg2 8. Kxg2 Qg7+ 9. Kh2 Qg6 10. Qxg6 hxg6 11. b4
and White wins. Now suppose that in the position in the preceding diagram it were Black’s move, and he played …Rf8. White would then simply defend his g Pawn by some move like Qf3 threatening Rxc6 and then he would bring his King up to g3 and when the time came, break through, as in the previous case. White might even be able to obtain the following position:
Black would now be forced to play …Rf8 and White could then play Qc2 and follow it up with Kf3 and thus force Black to play …fxg3 which would give White a greater advantage.
A careful examination of all these positions will reveal that, besides the advantage of freedom of manœuvre on White’s part, the power of the Pawn at e5 is enormous, and that it is the commanding position of this Pawn, and the fact that it is free to advance, once all the pieces are exchanged, that constitute the pivot of all White’s manœuvres.
I have purposely given positions without the moves which lead to them so that the student may become accustomed to build up in their own mind possible positions that may arise (out of any given situation). Thus he will learn to make strategical plans and be on their way to the master class. The student can derive enormous benefit by further practice of this kind.
6.3 The Influence of a "Hole"
The influence of a so-called ”hole” in a game has already been illustrated in my game against Blanco (Example 51), where has been shown the influence exercised by the different pieces posted in the hole created at e5.
Example 67
In order to further illustrate this point, I now give a game played in the Havana International Masters Tournament of 1913. (Queen’s Gambit Declined.) White: D. Janowski. Black: A. Kupchick.
1. d4 d5 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 Nf6 4. Bg5 Be7 5. e3 Nbd7 6. Bd3 dxc4 7. Bxc4 Nb6
Of course the idea is to post a Knight at d5 but as it is the other Knight which will be posted there this manœuvre does not seem logical. The Knight at b6 does nothing except to prevent the development of his own b Pawn. The normal course …O-O followed by …c5 is more reasonable. For a beautiful illustration of how to play White in that variation, see the Janowski-Rubinstein game of the St. Petersburg Tournament of 1914.
8. Bd3
Bb3 has some points in its favour in this position, the most important being the possibility of advancing the King’s Pawn immediately after 8. Bb3 Nfd5 9. Bxe7 Qxe7.
8... Nfd5 9. Bxe7 Qxe7 10. Nf3
Had White’s Bishop been at b3 he could now play e4 as indicated in the previous note, a move which he cannot make in the present position, because of …Nf4 threatening, not only the g Pawn, but also …Nxd3+. As White’s King’s Bishop should never be exchanged in this opening without a very good reason White therefore cannot play e4.
10... O-O 11. O-O Bd7 12. Rc1
White is perfectly developed, and now threatens to win a Pawn as follows: 13.Nxd5Nxd5,14.e4Nf4,15Rxc7.
12... c6
The fact that Black is practically forced to make this move in order to avoid the loss of a Pawn is sufficient reason in itself to condemn the whole system of development on Black’s part. In effect, he plays …Bd7 and now he has to shut off the action of his own Bishop, which thereby becomes little more than a Pawn for a while. In fact, it is hard to see how this Bishop will ever be able to attack anything. Besides, it can be easily seen that White will soon post his two Knights at e5 and c5 respectively, and that Black will not be able to dislodge them without seriously weakening his game, if he can do it at all. From all these reasons it can be gathered that it would probably have been better for Black to play …Nxc3 and thus get rid of one of the two White Knights before assuming such a defensive position. In such cases, the less the number of pieces on the board, the better chances there are to escape.
13. Ne4 f5
This practically amounts to committing suicide, since it creates a hole at e5 for White’s Knight, from where it will be practically impossible to dislodge him. If Black intended to make such a move he should have done it before, when at least there would have been an object in preventing the White Knight from reaching f4.
14. Nc5 Be8 15. Ne5
The position of White’s Knights, especially the one at e5 might be said to be ideal, and a single glance shows how they dominate the position. The question henceforth will be how is White going to derive the full benefit from such an advantageous situation, This we shall soon see.
15... Rb8
There is no object in this move, unless it is to be followed by …Nd7. As that is not the case, he might have gone with the Rook to c1 as he does later.
16. Re1 Rf6 17. Qf3 Rh6 18. Qg3 Rc8
White threatened to win the exchange by playing either Nf7 or Ng4.
19. f3 Rc7 20. a3 Kh8 21. h3
Perhaps all these precautions are unnecessary, but White feels that he has more than enough time to prepare his attack, and wants to be secure in every way before he begins.
21... g5 22. e4 f4 23. Qf2 Ne3
He had better have played …Nf6 and tried later on to get rid of White’s Knights by means of …Nd71.
24. Rxe3
with this sacrifice of the Rook for a Knight and Pawn White obtains an overwhelming position.
24... fxe3 25. Qxe3 Nc8
…Nd7 was better in order to get rid of one of the two White Knights. There were, however, any number of good replies to it, among them the following: 25…Nd7 26. Ncxd7 Bxd7 27. Qxg5 Qxg5 28. Nf7+ Kg7 29. Nxg5 and with two Pawns for the exchange, and the position so much in his favour, White should have no trouble in winning.
26. Ng4 Rg6 27. e5 Rg7 28. Bc4 Bf7
All these moves are practically forced, and as it is easily seen they tie up Black’s position more and more. White’s manœuvres from move 24 onwards are highly instructive.
29. Nf6 Nb6
This wandering Knight has done nothing throughout the game.
Note 1. Computer analysis disagrees with this assessment and suggest the move played …Ne3
30. Nce4 h6 31. h4 Nd5 32. Qd2 Rg6 33. hxg5 Qf8
If 33…hxg5 34. Kf2 and Black would be helpless.
34. f4 Ne7 35. g4 hxg5 36. fxg5
Resigns. There is nothing to be done. If …Bg8 Qh2+ Kg7 Bxe6. The student should notice that, apart from other things, White throughout the game has had control of the Black squares, principally those at e5 and c5.
From now on to the end of the book I shall give a collection of my games both lost and won, chosen so as to serve as illustrations of the general principles laid down in the foregoing pages.